Baking Up a Resistance

Mouth-watering chocolate cookies piled on a plate.

Anyone who wonders why people are baking for comfort these days has never come home to the olfactory bliss of fresh chocolate chip cookies. A few days ago I was feeling down. So I went searching for a legendary cookie recipe a friend sent me (and a thousand of her nearest and dearest) in the mid-1990s.  This recipe turned baking into an act of resistance.

Remember Neiman-Marcus? When I was little my mother treated shopping as a special girls’ outing. We’d have lunch in the café, then wander the aisles fondling things we could never buy—things I later decided I would never buy. Still, the place was a great favorite during our teenage shoplifting phase. Then it became part of an urban legend. Here’s the email:


Subject: Help me get even with Neiman-Marcus

One Saturday I took my daughter to Neiman-Marcus as a special treat. I bought a pretty scarf and a hair ribbon for my daughter. Then we had lunch in the café. I had a salad. She had grilled cheese. We decided to try the “Famous Neiman-Marcus Cookie” for dessert.  It was so delicious that I asked if the waitress would get me the recipe. She gave a little frown and said,      “I’m afraid not.”

“Well,” I said, “Would you let me buy the recipe?”

With a cute smile, she said, “Yes. Of course!”

When I asked how much, she responded, “Two-fifty.” I said, “Just add it to my tab.”

Her arched brows rose as she moistened her pencil and added it to my bill

A month later I heard the mail slip through the slot while I was doing the ironing. I opened my VISA statement and there was a bill from Neiman Marcus for $285.00. Can you believe it? Our lunch was $35—a lot at the time. The recipe was $250!” A month’s rent! I called the store right away and asked the manager to reduce my bill. I said I would send the recipe back.

She said, “Oh, no. You already have it. For all I know you might just copy it down.”

By now I was shaking with anger. I told her I would send this receipt to every cookie lover in my neighborhood. . . in the country. . . in the world! And they would never sell it again.

Unfazed, she replied, “I wish you wouldn’t.”

 And here, for you, is my revenge.


These cookies really are delicious.

I changed the recipe a smidge to up the comfort ratio.  

1 cup Unsalted Butter (2 sticks usually)

1/2 cup White Sugar

1 cup Brown Sugar

2 eggs

2 tsp vanilla

Blend moist ingredients until smooth then add to:

1 cup blended Oatmeal (chopped up in the blender)

1.5 cups flour

1/2 tsp salt

1 tsp baking soda

4 oz Hershey bar (grated) The secret ingredient

Choose from the following:

1.5 cups chopped nuts (I like walnuts best)

1.5 cups chocolate chips (semi-sweet!)

1.5 cups raisons or dried cranberries

Chill the dough if you're worried about cookie spread

Bake 8-10 minutes in oven preheated to 375 degrees

Cool before eating for the perfect crunch.

Makes about 2 dozen crunchy bits of paradise

Amanda Barusch

Amanda Barusch has worked as a janitor, exotic dancer, editor, and college professor. She lives in the American West, where she spends as much time as possible on dirt paths. She has an abiding disdain for boundaries and adores ambiguity. Amanda has published eight books of non-fiction, a few poems, and a growing number of short stories. Aging Angry is her first work of creative non-fiction. She uses magical realism to explore deep truths of the human experience in this rapidly changing world.

Previous
Previous

The Great Blueberry Muffin Battle

Next
Next

Nectar and Small